Press "Enter" to skip to content

Its Self-driving Automobile Suit Hastens . The Cost: A Chunk Of Uber

SAN FRANCISCO — At a sudden   conclusion  to an increasingly bitter public skirmish over self-driving automobile trade secrets, Uber settled a lawsuit Friday brought by Waymo, Google’s self-driving vehicle company, giving up a  stake to its rival.

As the fifth day of a trial was set to begin, Waymo announced the news in courtroom. According to the terms of the settlement, it will   receive 0.34 percent of Uber’s equity at a previous valuation high of $72 billion, which comes to approximately $245 million.

Partners along with investment firm SoftBank took a bet in Uber but at a valuation closer to $50 billion. Google was an early investor in Uber using a seat on its board. It attracted the suit .

The agreement follows a week of testimony which often shined a spotlight on the  aggressive  tactics of former Uber CEO Travis Kalanick, that led the firm since its founding in 2009 before June.

In Uber’s Friday announcement, new CEO Dara Khosrowshahi — hired in August after   Kalanick was ousted by investors due to mounting scandals — apologized to its competitor Waymo, agreed   to pay the fine and guaranteed  Uber would clean up its own act. Neither he nor Uber  confessed to receiving trade secrets.

“While I can’t erase the past, I can commit, on behalf of each Uber employee, that we will learn from it, and it’ll inform our actions going forward,” Khosrowshahi wrote. “As we change how we operate and put integrity at the core of every decision we make, we look forward to the fantastic race to build the future”

The sentiment contrasted with one testified regarding his recruiting of an engineer whose actions were in the heart of the dispute.

“As Uber’s statement indicates, no trade secrets came to Uber,” Kalanick said. “The evidence at trial proved that, and had the trial moved to its end, it is clear Uber could have prevailed.”

“The settlement represents the need for both businesses to move past this issue and get on with the objective of developing self-driving technology,” explained Karl Bauer, executive publisher of Cox Automotive.   Taking a piece of a rival’s inventory only typifies the ” ‘frenemy’ relationship pervading the modern technology industry,” he explained.

Creating ride-hailing cars autonomous is critical to businesses such as Uber and its rival Lyft, because paying the driver creates a business model with minimal room for profit.  

The turn of events followed four days through which Waymo, at least open sessions, didn’t appear to make much advancement proving its accusation that Uber had stolen trade secrets for its self-driving automobile app.

Waymo lawyers  painted former and present Uber workers conspiratorial at worst and shady at best. But given the days were committed to supplying proof of the theft of Google records, they had not yet highlighted what Waymo engineers LiDAR technology what revealed evidence that Uber utilized that information.

LiDAR utilizes lasers atop a self-driving car to help the vehicle “see” its environment. Though the technology is sophisticated, it’s readily available for purchase from providers such as Velodyne.  

Judge William Alsup made it apparent the trial wasn’t about Uber’s  business activities but whether Uber’s LiDAR was predicated on stolen data.

The settlement’s cost  might have been the clincher. Waymo had wanted at least $1 billion in damages and a public apology  Reuters reported in October. Uber had rejected these terms, it stated.

Settlement Covers a Uber year

Khosrowshahi has been in course-correction mode after a barbarous past year.   The executives of the company, on producing Uber the very popular and dominant service compelling at throttle, had cultivated a aggressive civilization that took little notice of standard business protocol and regulations.

The lawsuit of Waymo said Uber was developing detection and ranging strategies based on data discharged by former Waymo worker Anthony Levandowski, who began a truck company in 2016 which Uber bought in August of this year.    

The trial rehashed how Kalanick, who has called Levandowski a “brother from a different mother,” wooed the engineer while he was in Google. Levandowski wanted to start his own company and was frustrated by the speed of the program of Google. His partnership was invited by Kalanick, and eight months later Otto was set, Uber purchased it.  

The lawsuit alleged that Levandowski downloaded approximately 14,000 files from Google’s servers. These documents contained the key LiDAR information that Waymo accused  Uber of having to accelerate the progress of its car group. Google has worked  on Uber because 2015 and autonomous cars since 2009.

Khosrowshashi stated he didn’t believe Uber stole trade secrets but some workers may have inappropriately taken files from Google before they left.  

Waymo said in its  statement Friday that it was “committed to working with Uber (Google is an early investor in the ride-sharing company) to ensure each business develops its own technology.”

What remains unclear is whether the verdict or the litigation affects the self-driving car plan of Uber.

Khosrowshahi’s announcement says his company will be “taking actions with Waymo that ensure our LiDAR and software reflects just our good work,” suggesting some kind of tech tracking arrangement.  

If Uber’s LiDAR never had some Waymo trade secrets, then the company should have the ability to proceed as planned with its various car tests. If that is not the case, then it might have to rebuild its own LiDAR or retrofit its automobiles using LiDAR bought on the open market, a move that is costly and time consuming.

Waymo filed its lawsuit after it mistakenly got an email intended for Uber executives who included images of a LiDAR-related pc chip that Waymo said was identical to the own design.

Bro culture spotlight

Court testimony put a spotlight back on not just Kalanick, who has been largely from public opinion in recent months, but also on the “bro culture” air that permeates many tech businesses.

One of the numerous emails and text messages that were a part of the trial was just one message Levandowski delivered Kalanick containing a link to a brief video of Michael Douglas’ “Greed is Good” speech from Wall Street.  

Waymo attorneys convinced Alsup to allow them to perform the clip, implying that Kalanick, like Douglas’ character, Gordon Gekko, has been prepared to do anything.  

Notes from a meeting Kalanick had in 2015 included a list of items the CEO wanted like  a “pound of flesh”

The Shakespearean term has overtones. When asked on the witness stand why he used it, Kalanick shrugged: “I do not know specifically. It. I really don’t understand.”

Khosrowshahi has attempted to distance the company from his predecessor’s culture. He’s seeking  to enhance Uber’s connection with drivers, negotiate with towns such as London that threaten to boot the ceremony, and generally present a public face that contrasts with the take-no-prisoners approach of his predecessor.